The Most Morally Bankrupt Miles Blog Post Ever? Begging for First Class

Posted by Adam YWW on May 7, 2014 in Airlines, Bloggers

Things have been crazy with a new job and a new schedule.  Hope to finish trip reports soon.  But today, another blogger posted something that may be the most morally bankrupt post ever, and it compelled me to take a break and stay up later than I should.

Some background first….  Etihad Airways is the flag carrier of the United Arab Emirates, based on Abu Dhabi and owned by the government.  The UAE, and Abu Dhabi in particular, have absolutely horrible human rights records.  The United States and others look the other way because they have oil and foreign investment dollars.  For example, homosexuality is punishable by 14 years imprisonment in Abu Dhabi — and the law is enforced. Check out HRW’s latest country report here.

Etihad Airways is also one of the Gulf carriers that has pitched itself as a luxury carrier.  It’s most recent step in that direction was announced this week is the creation of “The Residences” on its A380 planes — a class above first class.  For the low price of about $21,000 for 1 or 2 persons, you can fly from London to Abu Dhabi  in a 3-room, 125 sq foot cabin, “with a living room, separate double bedroom (1.2m wide), ensuite shower room and personal butler, trained at London’s Savoy Butler Academy, as well as a travel concierge on hand, plus a chef to cook whatever passengers fancy.”  The flight is about 7 hours, the same as a flight from the East Coast to Western Europe.

Now, if you want to spend your money on this, go ahead.  There is no “need” for anyone to travel in this sort of luxury, and I think giving this money to the UAE is itself morally questionable.  But flying in luxury is nice, and I’ve enjoyed the two flights I’ve had in International First Class (from Bangkok to Paris, and Munich to New York), and I’ve also enjoyed business class flights when coach was really a perfectly reasonable alternative.

But can you imagine *fundraising* to get *other people* to pay for you to fly this route?  I could see if your grandma worked for 50 years in a garment factory, has a back condition, has never flown, and wants to see family in Abu Dhabi — then, maybe then, you could ask people to chip in for the ticket.   But what if you were in your mid-twenties, basically engaged in luxury travel for a living, and fly First Class internationally dozens of times a year?  Throw in that you are currently blogging about spending an entire year living in 4 and 5- star hotels?    Would you have the audacity to ask other people to pay for you to to fly there?  What if these were the same people who you already make all your money off of, by acting as their travel agent, and/or getting them to click on affiliate credit card links?

Well, it’s not a hypothetical, as Ben Schlappig, aka “Lucky” of One Mile at a Time has started a Kickstarter campaign to do exactly that:  begging for people to bankroll an entirely undeserving person flying from London to Dubai in ultra-luxury mainly so he can say he did, and snap some pictures and put it on his blog.  Why should you pay for him to do it?  Because, in his words “I’m the only person that has independently written reviews of every single A380 first class product currently in service, and have self-funded every one of those flights using miles.”   Well, someone call Pope Francis, because there’s a new martyr needing sainthood.

Maybe this is a case where someone is young and hasn’t quite realized the value of money, that having a sense of place, home, and community is worthwhile, and that a job where you contribute to society rather than talking about your luxury travel experiences is really a fulfilling part of life.  Or maybe I’m the naive one, thinking that other people would think this is the height of outrageous, greedy behavior?  After all, he has already gotten over $7000 in donations.

Unlike many other people who blog about points, miles, and travel, I have a full-time job in public service.  Luxury travel on vacations is something I recognize I am extremely fortunate to do, and I consider myself extremely lucky to be able to help the world on my day job, and then see the world on vacation.  And granted, I have been spoiled and sometimes find myself complaining about stupid things that most people in the world could only dream of.  But then sometimes, I read other blogs that engage in unethical sales practices, cheat companies or other travelers, or bring the level of complaining about minor luxuries to an insane level.  And I hate myself for even being involved in this hobby.   And then I see a post like this, and I think, what is wrong with the world?

Personally, I am going to make a donation to a human rights or poverty organization tomorrow.  I ask you to do the same.  I’ve posted some organizations in the comments, focusing on International Human Rights, LGBT issues, and poverty in Seattle — the area Ben has been “living” in — but feel free to chime in with your own.

*And to preempt some people who say this is an inappropriate personal attack.  You are wrong.  If I ever ask people on the internet to give me $20,000 — or even $2000, feel free to attack me about that request.

**Also note- he should pay taxes on this, as well as any other comped leisure travel he has been blogging about.  I don’t think the IRS is going to say this was a legitimate business expense.  Not legal advice, obviously. 🙂

Tags: , , , , , , ,

6 comments for “The Most Morally Bankrupt Miles Blog Post Ever? Begging for First Class”

  1. Adam1222 says:

    Some charities more worthy than Ben. And some are political, and some have huge flaws, but I’m confident a better argument can be made for all of them than giving $20,000 to a 20-something yutz so he can drink champagne and take pictures of airplane food.
    All also are particularly relevant to Ben’s situation.

    Human Rights Watch, http://secure.hrw.org/site/c.nlIWIgN2JwE/b.4542089/
    Immigration Equality, https://imeq.secure.force.com/donate
    International Rescue Committee, http://www.rescue.org/donate-overview
    United Nations Population Fund, http://www.unfpa.org/public/cache/offonce/home/donate;jsessionid=AEFA5D1902DFBB146AE6D73672A70683.jahia01
    International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission, https://iglhrc.org/content/support-our-work
    Northwest Justice Project (legal services in Seattle for low-income people) http://nwjustice.org/
    Columbia Legal Services (Same) http://columbialegal.org/
    Washington Community Alliance for Self-Help http://www.washingtoncash.org/donate-now

  2. Ron says:

    I think a lot of people are approaching the matter in the wrong way.

    It isn’t a question of whether there is a “more worthy” cause out there. If that were the question, then why do first and business class exist at all? Surely airlines and the people who fly in these cabins could settle for coach and instead donate the remainder? This in turn extends to practically every luxury product out there, of which I’m sure you’ll note are not in short supply.

    When people look at Ben’s campaign, the question they ask is not “would my money be better spent on starving children in Africa,” but “is the personal amusement I would gain from participating in this and reading the resulting trip report worth it?” Or since this is a Kickstarter campaign with backer rewards, is the offered reward worth the price of purchase?

    In that respect, it is no different from purchasing any other form of entertainment. When one goes to the bookstore, they do not ask themselves “should I buy a book or donate this money instead,” they ask themselves what book they would like to buy, and if there isn’t anything interesting, they’ll pocket the money for later. Or buy a movie instead. It’s no different from the myriad of Kickstarter projects asking for funding for a movie, documentary, or any other form of entertainment.

    It’s a frivolous expense to be sure, but all people have them. So indeed, what is wrong with a world where people can contribute to the entertainment they want to see at a price they feel is reasonable?

    1. Adam1222 says:

      When you pay $20 for a movie ticket, much of it goes to actual expenses in the supply chain. It reimburses art and hard work, yes, with a profit.
      Ben, however, is not an artist. Flying in luxury is not hard work, even if one takes photographs of themselves doing it.

    2. Adam1222 says:

      People pay money to watch cock fights as entertainment, too. It doesn’t make it right.

  3. Kyle says:

    There are “Rewards” for contributing at certain levels, and while I don’t actually expect this to get beyond the $5 mark, if this actually happens I’ll be mailing postcards, hosting dinners, and organizing other fun stuff around this flight.

    Seems someone is a little jealous of Lucky’s (much better) travel blog… sorry he doesnt have to work in public service LOL…

    Maybe stop bashing other reviewers (who could help you gain traction etc.) and make friends DUH!

    You’re worse than TPG and he has to remind everyone he is 6’7 in every review SAD!

    1. Adam YWW says:

      Hi Kyle T. Bakes! Thanks for stopping by and commenting on a post from four years ago. Hope you’re having a great day! And working in public service was one of the great privileges of my life! <3 (Unlike Lucky or TPG I'll let your comment through.) Hope your summer internship at Valley Forge Fabrics is going well!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Follow YWW

Visit Us On TwitterVisit Us On YoutubeCheck Our Feed